Example: 96413 and 96360 on a practitioner claim
In the v323r0 (2026 Q4) practitioner table, 96360 is a column-2 code to 96413: reported together on one date of service, 96413 is paid and 96360 denies as bundled. The pair carries modifier indicator 1, so a documented NCCI-associated modifier can separate the two services; the CMS rationale is "CPT Manual or CMS manual coding instruction" and the edit has been in effect since 2009-01-01. This is the answer the checker returns for the pair; the table below shows the other outcomes for common pairs.
Computed from the CMS practitioner PTP table (v323r0 (2026 Q4), effective 2026-10-01) when this page was built. Codes are bare numbers; open a pair to run it in the checker for either setting.
| Pair | Result | Modifier indicator | CMS rationale | Edit effective |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 96413 + 96360 | Bundled: 96360 into 96413 | 1 (modifier allowed) | CPT Manual or CMS manual coding instruction | 2009-01-01 |
| 43239 + 43235 | Bundled: 43235 into 43239 | 0 (no modifier) | CPT Separate procedure definition | 1996-01-01 |
| 99213 + 96372 | Bundled: 99213 into 96372 | 1 (modifier allowed) | Standards of medical/surgical practice | 2020-10-01 |
| 45380 + 45385 | Bundled: 45380 into 45385 | 1 (modifier allowed) | More extensive procedure | 2002-04-01 |
| 99213 + 36415 | No active edit | — | — | — |
What the tables contain
- Version
- v323r0 (2026 Q4)
- Effective
- 2026-10-01
- Practitioner pairs (active)
- 1732820
- 10,881 column-1 codes
- Hospital outpatient pairs (active)
- 1406699
- 10,011 column-1 codes
- Practitioner pairs with modifier allowed
- 70%
The National Correct Coding Initiative exists to stop payment for services that should not be reported together: a component that is part of a more comprehensive procedure, two codes that describe mutually exclusive ways of doing the same thing, or a service that is standard preparation or monitoring for another. CMS publishes the pairs quarterly as column-1 and column-2 code tables with a modifier indicator and a rationale, one table for practitioner claims and one for hospital outpatient claims processed through the Integrated Outpatient Code Editor. The pairs are directional: the column-1 code is the one that is paid, and reporting the column-2 code on the same date of service denies it as bundled. The rationales in the current file are 12 fixed categories, of which misuse of the column-2 code with the column-1 code, coding-manual instructions and standards of medical and surgical practice account for most pairs.
Checking an older date of service
NCCI edits are applied by date of service, and every quarterly file records when each pair took effect and, once CMS retires it, its deletion date: the last date of service the edit applies to. Without a date the lookup answers from the pairs in force in the current quarter. With a date from 2024-01-01 to 2026-12-31 it leaves out pairs that took effect after that date and brings back pairs CMS has deleted since, so a corrected claim or an appeal for an earlier visit is checked against the edits that applied then. The current files hold 29,220 practitioner and 22,813 hospital outpatient pairs deleted in that window (11,846 with a 2024 deletion date, 16,643 with a 2025 deletion date, 731 with a 2026 deletion date on the practitioner side). Pairs marked with modifier indicator 9 were deleted retroactively and never applied, so a date of service never brings them back. The file states only the current modifier indicator and rationale, so if CMS changed an indicator in an earlier quarter, confirm it in the archived file for that quarter before an appeal.
Medicaid NCCI edits
State Medicaid programs apply their own NCCI tables, and the lookup reads the national Medicaid files for 2026 Q4 when you choose Medicaid: 1,825,786 practitioner pairs, 1,505,274 outpatient hospital pairs and a durable medical equipment table of 43,690 pairs that Medicare does not have. Against Medicare, the Medicaid practitioner table adds 93,598 pairs, omits 632 and gives 1,829 shared pairs a different modifier indicator, so each Medicaid answer also states what Medicare does with the same pair. For example, 11922 with 96374 is bundled in the Medicaid practitioner table (modifier indicator 1, rationale "Standards of medical/surgical practice") but not in Medicare's. CMS states that its public Medicaid files should not be used by state Medicaid programs as their edit file, because states run the files CMS sends them and may have edits deactivated, so a Medicaid answer is a reference point for the state program or plan rather than its final word. The Medicaid vs Medicare NCCI comparison counts every difference.
Modifiers that can separate a pair
A modifier only bypasses the edit when the record shows a separate session, site, practitioner, incision or injury; appending 59 to force payment is the fastest route to a post-payment review.
| Modifier | When it applies |
|---|---|
| 59 | Distinct procedural service, when no more specific X modifier applies |
| XE | Separate encounter on the same date |
| XS | Separate organ or structure |
| XP | Separate practitioner |
| XU | Unusual, non-overlapping service |
| 25 | Significant, separately identifiable E/M service on the day of a procedure |
| 57 | E/M decision for surgery on the day of or before a major procedure |
| E1-E4, FA, F1-F9, TA, T1-T9, LT, RT, LC, LD, RC, LM, RI | Anatomic modifiers that show different sites (eyelids, fingers, toes, sides of the body and coronary arteries) |
| 24, 27, 58, 78, 79, 91 | Global-period and repeat-service modifiers CMS lists as NCCI-associated |
Since 2015 CMS has asked for the X modifiers in place of 59 whenever one of them fits, because they say why the service was distinct instead of merely asserting it. Modifier 25 is used on the evaluation and management code, not on the procedure, when the visit was significant and separately identifiable; the pair edit between an E/M code and a minor procedure is what that modifier exists to address. None of the modifiers works on a pair with indicator 0, and none makes an unbundled service medically necessary; the coverage policies still decide that.
Using the checker in a billing workflow
Run the pair before the claim goes out whenever two procedure codes share a date of service, and again when a denial arrives. A bundled result with indicator 1 means the claim can carry an NCCI-associated modifier if the documentation supports a distinct service; a bundled result with indicator 0 means the column-2 code should be removed and the column-1 code billed alone, because no modifier will be honoured and the appeal has no basis in the edit. A pair that is not bundled can still deny for units, which the MUE lookup answers, or for an add-on code reported without its primary, which the checker flags from the CMS add-on code edits, or under a payer's own bundling policy, since Medicare Advantage plans and commercial payers run their own edit sets that start from NCCI but do not end there. State Medicaid programmes apply a separate Medicaid NCCI table that differs in places from the Medicare one, which the Medicaid setting above reads. On the remittance, NCCI bundling appears as CARC 97 with remark M15, or as reason code 236; the denial pages cover the appeal.
The address bar keeps the pair you checked (for example #a=96413&b=96360, with &p=medicaid or a date of service added when you choose them), so a check can be shared with a colleague and opens with the same codes; the HCPCS drug code pages link here with their code already filled in. Publishers can add the same lookup to their own site with the embeddable NCCI checker. The checker answers one pair at a time from a packed copy of the CMS tables on the server; it does not list every partner of a code, because that list is the CMS file itself and belongs in an encoder. The per-code exposure, meaning how many pairs name a drug code as column 2 and what share allow a modifier, is on each HCPCS drug code page, and the methodology page records the file versions and hashes behind every number. Once a pair clears, the Medicare fee lookup shows the RVUs and 2026 physician fee schedule payment for the paid code in any locality.
What changed this quarter
The NCCI 2026 Q4 changes report summarizes the pairs CMS added, deleted and re-flagged on 2026-10-01, code by code, with the MUE additions and revisions for the same release. The ranking of the codes NCCI bundles most ranks the 50 codes that are column 2 in the most active pairs in each table; any code in either report opens here with its code filled in.
Add the NCCI edits lookup to your site
Billing companies, coding educators and practice websites can embed this checker for free. Paste the snippet below where the widget should appear: the script loads the same lookup in a frame served from quickintell.com, with the Medicare and Medicaid tables, the claim settings and the date-of-service field, and keeps every result inside the frame. Set data-program="medicaid" to open it on the Medicaid tables, or data-setting="hospital" for outpatient claims. The attribution link to this page is a condition of use; if it is missing or hidden, the script adds it below the widget. The widget stores nothing and sets no cookies on your page, and it follows each quarterly CMS release automatically.
<div class="quickintell-ncci-checker" data-program="medicare">
<a href="https://quickintell.com/tools/ncci-checker">NCCI edits lookup</a> by <a href="https://quickintell.com/">QuickIntell</a>
</div>
<script src="https://quickintell.com/embed/ncci-checker.js" async></script>For teams evaluating QuickIntell software
Where QuickIntell fits in coding review
This checker answers one pair at a time. QuickCode supports qualified coder review, documentation clarification and the billing handoff, where pair edits and modifier support are settled on the whole claim.
Optional software evaluation, not payer support or help with an individual claim. For coverage or payment decisions, use the official sources on this page. Do not include patient information in a demo booking or inquiry.
Frequently asked questions
What is an NCCI procedure-to-procedure edit?
A PTP edit is a pair of HCPCS or CPT codes that CMS will not pay together for the same patient on the same date of service by the same provider. The column-1 code is paid and the column-2 code denies as bundled, unless the pair carries modifier indicator 1 and a documented NCCI-associated modifier is appended.
What do modifier indicators 0, 1 and 9 mean?
Indicator 0 means no modifier can separate the pair; the column-2 code is never paid with the column-1 code. Indicator 1 means an NCCI-associated modifier such as 59, XE, XS, XP, XU, 25 or an anatomic modifier bypasses the edit when the record supports a distinct service. Indicator 9 marks edits that were deleted retroactively and are not applied.
Why are there separate practitioner and hospital tables?
CMS publishes one PTP table for practitioner claims processed under the Physician Fee Schedule and another, applied through the Integrated Outpatient Code Editor, for hospital outpatient facility claims. Most pairs appear in both, but the hospital table omits edits that do not apply to facility billing and adds a few of its own, so the checker asks which claim you are testing.
How current is this checker?
It uses the 2026 Q4 practitioner and hospital PTP tables, version v323r0, effective October 1, 2026, and the Medicaid NCCI files for the same quarter. Without a date of service it reads the pairs in force now; with one it also uses the pairs CMS deleted since January 1, 2024. CMS updates the tables quarterly; the January 2027 release replaces this one.
Can I check a pair for an earlier date of service?
Yes. Enter a date of service from January 1, 2024 to the end of the current quarter. The checker then leaves out edits whose effective date falls after that date and still applies edits CMS deleted later, up to their deletion date, which is what a corrected claim or an appeal for an older visit needs. The modifier indicator and rationale shown are the current ones, so check an appeal against the archived CMS file for that quarter.
Does the checker cover Medicaid NCCI edits?
Yes. Choose Medicaid to read the national Medicaid NCCI tables for practitioner, outpatient hospital or durable medical equipment claims; the answer also says how Medicare treats the same pair. CMS notes that its public Medicaid files should not be used by states as their edit file, so confirm a denial with the state program or Medicaid plan.
Why are the code descriptions missing?
CPT descriptors are copyrighted by the American Medical Association and QuickIntell does not hold a distribution license for public display. The checker shows bare code numbers; HCPCS Level II descriptors are public and appear on the HCPCS drug code pages.
Which denial codes does an NCCI edit produce?
The remittance usually carries claim adjustment reason code 97 (the benefit for this service is included in the payment for another service) with remark M15, or reason code 236 (this procedure is not compatible with another procedure provided on the same day according to NCCI). The denial pages for both explain the appeal path.
Does the checker test add-on codes?
Yes. Alongside the bundling answer, the checker reads the CMS add-on code edits for the same quarter. When one code of the pair is an add-on code and the other is not one of its listed primary codes, it says so: billed on a practitioner claim without a listed primary, the add-on line is denied, usually with reason code 107 and remark N122. On a standard hospital outpatient claim (bill type 013x) the outpatient code editor applies its add-on edit only to remote mental health and software-as-a-service add-on codes, and the hospital result says so. For type 2 add-on codes CMS lists no primaries, so the contractor's own list applies.
Why does a hospital outpatient claim show I/OCE edit 20 or 40?
Hospital outpatient claims are edited by the Integrated Outpatient Code Editor, which carries the hospital PTP table as edit 20 (the pair allows no modifier) and edit 40 (the pair allows a modifier, but none is on the line). Both reject the column-two line, which can be corrected and resubmitted. Choose the hospital outpatient setting above to see the pair as the I/OCE applies it.
Related references: what every I/OCE edit and disposition means on an outpatient claim, the add-on code edit types and primaries, a chapter-by-chapter guide to the NCCI Policy Manual, and the NCCI reference hub with edit counts by rationale and code range.
Sources
Every figure on this page is taken from the CMS publications below, as released by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Projection built 2026-11-16. Verify against the primary file before billing or contracting decisions. The reference methodology explains how each figure is computed from these files.
- NCCI PTP edits, practitioner, v323r0 (four files)Version v323r0 (2026 Q4) · effective 2026-10-01 · file ccipra-v323r0-f1.TXTSHA-256 7793c0b6686c1e22…
- NCCI PTP edits, hospital outpatient, v323r0 (four files)Version v323r0 (2026 Q4) · effective 2026-10-01 · file ccioph-v323r0-f1.txtSHA-256 063f41b91ef9faa2…
- NCCI Add-On Code edits, effective 2026-10-01Version 2026 Q4 · effective 2026-10-01 · file AOC_V2026Q4-F-MCR.xlsxSHA-256 eabb519623134549…
- Medicaid NCCI PTP edits, practitioner services, effective 2026-10-01Version 2026 Q4 · effective 2026-10-01 · file MCD-PTP-PractitionerServices-Effective_10012026.txtSHA-256 142cc2fb5002027d…
- Medicaid NCCI PTP edits, outpatient hospital services, effective 2026-10-01Version 2026 Q4 · effective 2026-10-01 · file MCD-PTP-OutpatientHospitalServices-Effective_10012026.txtSHA-256 23b17c9a8894821b…
- Medicaid NCCI PTP edits, durable medical equipment services, effective 2026-10-01Version 2026 Q4 · effective 2026-10-01 · file MCD-PTP-DMEServices-Effective_10012026.txtSHA-256 42c219a52f3ad2af…
Disclaimer
Operational reference compiled from the CMS NCCI quarterly files. Payment also depends on documentation, the payer's own edits and coverage policy. CPT codes appear as bare numbers. Not legal, clinical or billing advice.
Found a figure that does not match the CMS file? Report a data correction with the CMS file and the value you expected; the request reaches the editorial team through the contact form.